News:

The least-anticipated revival since Fuller House is finally here! Against all odds, the Excel
Saga Forum is back with its original domain name intact. Read the announcement thread for
more details, or check out the Resources section for help finding copies of both the manga and
anime. And don't forget to join our newfangled Discord if that's the kind of thing you're into!

Main Menu

The End of Excel Saga (in Japan)

Started by Sean Gaffney, March 03, 2011, 02:43:05 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Foggle

Strange... Can't find anything about a password anywhere on his blog. The file size definitely makes it look legit.

Uncreativity

I'm stumped myself. It doesn't seem to be the blog url (with or without http://).  ???

Duomaxwe

Are you guys looking into it?

I also downloaded a 400mb Holy Brownie one, and it's passworded too.

Uncreativity

The more I compare the volume 27 tankobon to the original YKO scans, the more dialogue discrepancies I find, not just in the final chapter, but in the entire volume. Some of them are pretty significant, too, like:

[spoiler="THIS IS A GIANT SPOILER I AM NOT EVEN KIDDING. CLICK AT YOUR OWN RISK."]In the original version, the proto-Il Palazzo and Excel cores are referred to as Arc and Accord, respectively.

The original line is, "Arc... it's me, Accord."
The new one is, "Pio... it's me."

Do you see where it's going here? The original Excel and Il Palazzo... were actually Fio and Piora. From Holy Brownie. Some of the extra pages visually confirm it as well.

At the moment I read that, I think I must have looked like this:
[/spoiler]

Sean Gaffney

I can't wait for Carl's endnote on that one.  >_>

Lord Il

Quote from: Uncreativity on November 08, 2011, 02:25:50 PM
The more I compare the volume 27 tankobon to the original YKO scans, the more dialogue discrepancies I find, not just in the final chapter, but in the entire volume. Some of them are pretty significant, too, like:

[spoiler="THIS IS A GIANT SPOILER I AM NOT EVEN KIDDING. CLICK AT YOUR OWN RISK."]In the original version, the proto-Il Palazzo and Excel cores are referred to as Arc and Accord, respectively.

The original line is, "Arc... it's me, Accord."
The new one is, "Pio... it's me."

Do you see where it's going here? The original Excel and Il Palazzo... were actually Fio and Piora. From Holy Brownie. Some of the extra pages visually confirm it as well.

At the moment I read that, I think I must have looked like this:
[/spoiler]
I... I d-don't even... *head explodes to smithereens*

Duomaxwe

I see people aren't worrying about the download I posted..

I don't have either the YKO with the final chapter in it, or the 27th volume.

Can someone help me out?

Uncreativity

Like I said, I haven't been able to figure out the password. The reason why I know what happens in volume 27 is because I actually purchased a physical copy.

Foggle

Quote from: Uncreativity on November 08, 2011, 02:25:50 PM
The more I compare the volume 27 tankobon to the original YKO scans, the more dialogue discrepancies I find, not just in the final chapter, but in the entire volume. Some of them are pretty significant, too, like:

[spoiler="THIS IS A GIANT SPOILER I AM NOT EVEN KIDDING. CLICK AT YOUR OWN RISK."]In the original version, the proto-Il Palazzo and Excel cores are referred to as Arc and Accord, respectively.

The original line is, "Arc... it's me, Accord."
The new one is, "Pio... it's me."

Do you see where it's going here? The original Excel and Il Palazzo... were actually Fio and Piora. From Holy Brownie. Some of the extra pages visually confirm it as well.

At the moment I read that, I think I must have looked like this:
[/spoiler]
WHAT THE FUCK

...

RIKDOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

HA1L ILPALLAZZO

i havent look at the spoiler or bought the japanese but in the end i dont want to spoil it for me lol. I mean sure i have seen spoilers for the last few issues but i dont wanna spoil the ending i reckon i'll be more satisfied that way :-)


SWamP

Excel Saga fan, which do you choose?

[spoiler]The bittersweet ending (magazine) or the brainfuck ending (tankobon)?

That's the drill... -_-U

Rikudo, you're an ass :p[/spoiler]

Duomaxwe

Has anyone actually read Holy Brownie?

HA1L ILPALLAZZO

yep its about 2 time travelling pixies trying to solve certain problems. Its full of sex and violence and is funny lmao


Duomaxwe

It's not in English anywhere though no?

Sean Gaffney

It hasn't been scanlated that I know of, no.  And is far too explicit for Viz to realistically pick up, even if it did have a chance of selling.  Which it does not.