News:

The least-anticipated revival since Fuller House is finally here! Against all odds, the Excel
Saga Forum is back with its original domain name intact. Read the announcement thread for
more details, or check out the Resources section for help finding copies of both the manga and
anime. And don't forget to join our newfangled Discord if that's the kind of thing you're into!

Main Menu

Your Favorite and Least Favorite Episodes?

Started by Foggle, October 06, 2007, 08:04:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Randamo

i just thought it was awkard, but, meh, personal opinion.
y'know i really disliked the softball episode. i only liked the part where excel was singing at the start.

MarkH

Fave Episodes : Love Puny, Butt Out Youth, Visually Appealing Type.

Episodes I Hate : Menchi's Great Adventure, The Story Of Mr Pedro (pointless recap episode) and For You I Could Die (sorry, but an Excel Saga episode without humour is NOT 'true' Excel Saga, IMO)

Foggle

Quote from: MarkH on November 04, 2007, 03:58:58 AM
an Excel Saga episode without humour is NOT 'true' Excel Saga, IMO

It was kinda' funny... in parts.  Have you read the manga? O.o

skycloud



I have to find a time in the near future to go back and restore the world.
                 -Kyon

E^D Crow

Quote from: Foggle on November 04, 2007, 07:24:07 AM
Quote from: MarkH on November 04, 2007, 03:58:58 AM
an Excel Saga episode without humour is NOT 'true' Excel Saga, IMO

It was kinda' funny... in parts.  Have you read the manga? O.o
I dug "For you, I could die".  It's close to the same tone of the manga.  I also liked "The Interesting Giant Tower" for the same reason.

Least favorites: both Minci episodes, and the Pedro recap...

The thing I liked best about "Going Too Far", was the just about proper
(but still too much) amount of blood Hayatt spewed.  The majority of the series was tame when it came to the rather shocking amount that she vomits up in the manga. :hdead:

E^D

Foggle

Quote from: E^D Crow on November 04, 2007, 06:40:12 PM
Quote from: Foggle on November 04, 2007, 07:24:07 AM
Quote from: MarkH on November 04, 2007, 03:58:58 AM
an Excel Saga episode without humour is NOT 'true' Excel Saga, IMO

It was kinda' funny... in parts.  Have you read the manga? O.o
I dug "For you, I could die".  It's close to the same tone of the manga.  I also liked "The Interesting Giant Tower" for the same reason.

Least favorites: both Minci episodes, and the Pedro recap...

The thing I liked best about "Going Too Far", was the just about proper
(but still too much) amount of blood Hayatt spewed.  The majority of the series was tame when it came to the rather shocking amount that she vomits up in the manga. :hdead:

E^D

Yeah, For You I Could Die is one of my favorites, too, thus my comment about the manga.  I also thought that The Interesting Giant Tower was great.

I actually liked the second Menchi episode, though, it was rather funny.

Considering that the show was aired late at night, why didn't they put the proper amount of Hyatt blood in the other episodes? O.o

skycloud

Hyatt isnt shown bleeding all that much even in the manga...


I have to find a time in the near future to go back and restore the world.
                 -Kyon

Foggle

Quote from: skycloud117 on November 06, 2007, 04:23:06 PM
Hyatt isnt shown bleeding all that much even in the manga...

While I wouldn't classify the amount of blood in the manga as "shocking," "disgusting," or "disturbing," she still bleeds quite a bit.

skycloud

I think the worst one was the bathtub bomb incident where she went off like a sprinkler


I have to find a time in the near future to go back and restore the world.
                 -Kyon

E^D Crow

Quote from: Foggle on November 06, 2007, 04:49:32 PM
Quote from: skycloud117 on November 06, 2007, 04:23:06 PM
Hyatt isnt shown bleeding all that much even in the manga...

While I wouldn't classify the amount of blood in the manga as "shocking," "disgusting," or "disturbing," she still bleeds quite a bit.

There are many instances where she is either spewing more then a little from her mouth, or is found lying in a puddle.  I called it rather shocking, because it is much more then a simple nosebleed or even a deep cut.  It's more like the amount that would come from a lost limb... except from her mouth.  :hdead:

E^D

Randamo

worst one would be for elgala when they were in the  hobo shack, elgala looks non-chanantly to hyatt and blood caomes out of her mouth and elgala has this freeeked out expression. worst one i reckon.
oooh, the most shocking when thoses birds ate hyatts pill and died. that was creepy.
sorry, off topic. :excel_fall:

skycloud



I have to find a time in the near future to go back and restore the world.
                 -Kyon

Randamo

huhnn!?
well, i guess im the person who goes off topic the most (in fact, right now is an example), but thats an odd comment so this is the consequence: :excel_fall:
later (4U)

skycloud



I have to find a time in the near future to go back and restore the world.
                 -Kyon

Foggle