News:

The least-anticipated revival since Fuller House is finally here! Against all odds, the Excel
Saga Forum is back with its original domain name intact. Read the announcement thread for
more details, or check out the Resources section for help finding copies of both the manga and
anime. And don't forget to join our newfangled Discord if that's the kind of thing you're into!

Main Menu

The End of Excel Saga (in Japan)

Started by Sean Gaffney, March 03, 2011, 02:43:05 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Foggle

Quote from: HA1L ILPALLAZZO on October 24, 2011, 06:54:07 AM
what we should do to mark this occasion is organise a world wide meet up. It'll be awhile yet so we can start saving up now for it lol
Oh, hell yeah! I'd love to meet all you guys. Hopefully we can get some of the currently AWOL people (like Micki!) there, too. :im_nabeshin:

We should hold it in Fukuoka. ;)

Randamo

Just need to save a thousand a year; so just save $20 a week and by 2016 we can all watch the cherry blossoms and drink sake in Fukuoka!

Lord Il

Due to time constraints (much having to do with my work hours and some RL stuff), I'm prevented from talking with you all a lot more than I'd like. -_- Despite this, I consider you guys kinda like an online family. This is the longest forum I've ever been involved with and I'm happy to be part of it. :e_pleased:

It would be terrific to meet everyone here!

Foggle

Quote from: Lord Il on October 25, 2011, 01:59:59 PM
I consider you guys kinda like an online family. This is the longest forum I've ever been involved with and I'm happy to be part of it. :e_pleased:
I feel the same way! :elhail:

E-E

Wow I have got alot of vols to catch up on  :ehail:

Lord Il

Quote from: E-E on October 29, 2011, 04:48:07 AM
Wow I have got alot of vols to catch up on  :ehail:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Ktv3BnX3KQ



:il_hahaha:
But seriously, it's great to have you back! :ehail:

Duomaxwe

How do you order the final volume from HMV.co.jp?

It's hard to figure out how to register.

Sean Gaffney

Keep your copies of September's Young King Ours if you have them - Rikdo reworked the ending chapter for the 27th tankobon. 

[spoiler]Less chaotic, more sentimental, IMO.  Adds the Leiji Matsumoto Parody characters for a brief cameo, gives Watanabe a much happier ending, and has a "I drew this for you, Uncreativity" final page.  And no, the volume does not include either of the 'hot spring' epilogues.

But yes, it still has that Shiouji ending.  WTF.[/spoiler]

SWamP

Quote from: Sean Gaffney on November 05, 2011, 05:19:00 AM
Keep your copies of September's Young King Ours if you have them - Rikdo reworked the ending chapter for the 27th tankobon. 

[spoiler]Less chaotic, more sentimental, IMO.  Adds the Leiji Matsumoto Parody characters for a brief cameo, gives Watanabe a much happier ending, and has a "I drew this for you, Uncreativity" final page.  And no, the volume does not include either of the 'hot spring' epilogues.

But yes, it still has that Shiouji ending.  WTF.[/spoiler]

So... The Young King Ours ending was a Gainax ending... nice...

RIKUDOOOOOO!

Uncreativity

#84
EXCITING :ehail:

ETA: IN FACT! I am going out to buy it right now.

Uncreativity

That page that was drawn just for me?

[spoiler=HERE IT IS]

Sorry about the bad scans. I didn't want to ruin my book![/spoiler]

Foggle

Quote from: Sean Gaffney on November 05, 2011, 05:19:00 AM
Keep your copies of September's Young King Ours if you have them - Rikdo reworked the ending chapter for the 27th tankobon. 

[spoiler]Less chaotic, more sentimental, IMO.  Adds the Leiji Matsumoto Parody characters for a brief cameo, gives Watanabe a much happier ending, and has a "I drew this for you, Uncreativity" final page.  And no, the volume does not include either of the 'hot spring' epilogues.

But yes, it still has that Shiouji ending.  WTF.[/spoiler]
Holy poop on a post! Glad I bought the magazine. :elhail:

No heavy spoilers please, but... how different are we talking here? Like, is nothing the same (not even the art), or were just a few scenes changed into something else? Oh yeah, and which ending is better/more satisfying/more fitting/whatever?

Sean Gaffney

[spoiler]Most of it is roughly the same, up until Kabapu and Momochi's 'epilogue' scene'.  It them gives Watanabe, Elgala and Hyatt a rewrite, and adds Mr. Owner and Ms. Manager in a cameo.  It also adds a scene with Excel, Il Palazzo and Tenmangu (I think, don't read Japanese, so going by pictures.)  Then we get Shiouji and Umi's scene as it was in the magazine, only Menchi is now with Umi.  The final shot is what you see in Uncreativity's post above - the last "Excel Saga... in... SPAAAAACE!" scene is totally gone.

As I said, I dunno about good or bad, especially since I can't read it.  It does give off a feel of "more of a happy ending".[/spoiler]

Foggle

Quote from: Sean Gaffney on November 06, 2011, 01:44:47 AM
[spoiler]Most of it is roughly the same, up until Kabapu and Momochi's 'epilogue' scene'.  It them gives Watanabe, Elgala and Hyatt a rewrite, and adds Mr. Owner and Ms. Manager in a cameo.  It also adds a scene with Excel, Il Palazzo and Tenmangu (I think, don't read Japanese, so going by pictures.)  Then we get Shiouji and Umi's scene as it was in the magazine, only Menchi is now with Umi.  The final shot is what you see in Uncreativity's post above - the last "Excel Saga... in... SPAAAAACE!" scene is totally gone.

As I said, I dunno about good or bad, especially since I can't read it.  It does give off a feel of "more of a happy ending".[/spoiler]
Thanks! That does sound like a much better conclusion. :im_nabeshin:
Now let's get an anime remake up in this bitch. :il_hahaha:

Duomaxwe

http://blog.goo.ne.jp/orochima/e/627408580ce0b268090a6e249f0d96f0

I found this thing which claims to be a RAR of Excel Saga 27, but it's password protected.

What do you guys say?